jhall1, I am going to have to admit defeat on your request for my top 5 books which should never have been filmed - I just can't think of any! Please feel free to ask for another top 5!
I'm surprised, as my experience is that if a favourite book is made into a film or TV series it's almost always a disappointment. Having said which, I concede that the LotR films had more good points than bad, and I thoroughly enjoyed the Narnia film.
Asd a substitute, I'll use my "standard" question, which I don't think that anyone else has yet asked you. What are your 5 favourite SF and/or fantasy books.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
momijizukamori
no subject
Date: 2006-01-26 06:46 pm (UTC)I'm surprised, as my experience is that if a favourite book is made into a film or TV series it's almost always a disappointment. Having said which, I concede that the LotR films had more good points than bad, and I thoroughly enjoyed the Narnia film.
Asd a substitute, I'll use my "standard" question, which I don't think that anyone else has yet asked you. What are your 5 favourite SF and/or fantasy books.